In the dark and turbulent 1930s in New York City, the city made headlines with stories that were both disturbing and unbelievable. Among these is the story of Michael Malloy, a homeless Irishman from County Donegal who survived over 20 assassination attempts before finally meeting his end at the hands of his own friends. His story is one of greed, betrayal and a remarkable resilience that eclipsed even the most ruthless criminals. Michael Malloy, affectionately known as ‘Mike the Durable’, ‘Iron Mike’ or ‘Rasputin of the Bronx’ – as, like the Russian monk, he survived several assassination attempts before he was finally killed – lived in poverty. He had lost his job as a firefighter during the Great Depression and sought solace in alcohol. For most people, that would have been a tragic fate in itself, but for Malloy, the truly incomprehensible was only just beginning. In January 1933, a group of five of his ‘friends’ hatched a deadly plan. Tony Marino, Joseph ‘Red’ Murphy, Francis Pasqua, Hershey Green and Daniel Kriesberg joined forces to form a gang that would soon become notorious as ‘The Murder Trust’. Their aim was to commit life insurance fraud by murdering Malloy. With the help of a corrupt insurance agent, they took out a total of three life insurance policies in Malloy’s name, under the pseudonym Nicholas Mellory. Should Malloy die in an accident, the perpetrators stood to gain a fortune of over 3,500 USD at the time – equivalent to over 85,000 USD today. The plan seemed simple. Malloy was known for his insatiable thirst for alcohol. He was given unlimited supplies at Tony Marino’s speakeasy on New York’s 3rd Avenue, with the aim of getting him to drink himself to death there. Yet despite his unlimited alcohol consumption, Malloy miraculously remained alive. Marino therefore resorted to more drastic measures and spiked Malloy’s drinks with antifreeze. Yet Malloy carried on drinking as if he were immune to the poison. One possible explanation could be that ethanol blocks the absorption of ethylene glycol in the liver – a recognised antidote for antifreeze poisoning. The measures taken to kill Malloy became increasingly extreme. They replaced the antifreeze with turpentine, followed by horse ointment and rat poison, all of which found their way into Malloy’s drinks. The Irishman’s stubborn resistance drove the group of men to the brink of despair. Finally, they tried a lethal meal, feeding Malloy raw oysters soaked in methanol. This idea was based on a morbid rumour that Pasqua had picked up. Even a sandwich made of rotten sardines laced with poison and carpet tacks had no effect. In their frustration, the men decided to expose Malloy to New York’s merciless winter. On a freezing evening with temperatures below minus 26 °C, the drunken Malloy was thrown into the snow in Crotona Park and doused with ice-cold water. But fate had other plans. The police found Malloy and took him to a homeless shelter, where he was provided with clothes and warmth. This marked yet another failed attempt on his life. As time was running out and the bounties were about to expire, the group decided on a brutal plan. They wanted to run Malloy over with Green’s taxi. They propped up the drunken Malloy and were ready to jump aside as Green raced towards him at a speed of 72 km/h. However, it was only on the third attempt that Malloy’s body struck the bonnet and he fell to the ground. Green then reversed his taxi and ran him over. The group believed Malloy to be dead, but were unable to confirm this because a passing car scared them off. Malloy, however, was lucky once again: he was discovered by police and taken to Fordham Hospital, where his broken bones were treated. Once Malloy had fully recovered, the gang planned a final attempt on his life. On 22 February 1933, after Malloy had once again slept off his drunkenness, they took him to Murphy’s room. There, the group carried out their treacherous plan by shoving a gas hose into his mouth and turning on the gas. Within an hour, the life of the indestructible Malloy was extinguished, officially certified as ‘pneumonia’. Yet the stories of ‘Mike the Durable’ spread through the city’s speakeasies and caught the attention of the police. An exhumation followed, accompanied by a forensic examination that uncovered the criminal machinations. The five men soon stood trial and were found guilty. Whilst Dr Frank Manzella, who had signed the death certificate, received only a minor sentence, Marino, Pasqua, Murphy and Kriesberg were executed by electric chair at Sing Sing Prison in June and July 1934. Green was convicted of attempted murder and had to serve at least ten years in prison. What remains is the remarkable story of a man who did not give in, even in the face of death at the hands of his supposed friends. Michael Malloy, the ‘indestructible’ Irishman, remains a symbol of how life can take astonishing turns even under the worst of circumstances. And so his legend lives on, a memorial to those who believe that the perfect crime is merely a matter of planning.



